Protestors with an “End The Lockdown$” sign at Science World in Vancouver on May 3, 2020. (Desire Amouzou photo)

COLUMN: The call for full-scale economic reopening is an argument to cull the herd

If you believe the weak and elderly are expendable to save the economy, then please say so

Michael Grace was 89 years old when he died of complications due to COVID-19 at his long-term care home in Chilliwack.

He was born on April 10, 1931 at Ottawa General Hospital and moved to the Lower Mainland in 1962 where he lived a long life, working in the automotive industry, enjoying life on a farm, breeding horses.

That’s according to his obituary. I didn’t know Mr. Grace, nor do I know any of the approximately 150 people who have died in B.C. as a result of this novel coronavirus.

What I do know is that we are now in the process of lifting restrictions as part of phase two of getting the economy and our lives back to some semblance of new normal. There are those, however, who have screamed from the rooftops that this has all been a scam, that COVID-19 is nothing more than “the sniffles,” that seasonal influenza kills more people, and that the cost to the economy to do what is needed to be done has been too high.

• READ MORE: B.C. sees 2 deaths, 16 new COVID-19 cases over May long weekend on eve of phase two

What is left unsaid among those decrying public health orders, and the government and public health response so far, is quite simply that they would have been willing to trade the lives of the elderly and those otherwise immune-compromised.

They would have been willing to, essentially, cull the herd.

Conrad Black wrote in a recent column that the response to COVID-19 is “overblown,” and that the danger of death for 80 per cent of us is statistically insignificant so it’s time to end the “lockdown.” (Of course, no province has been in a “lockdown,” despite the irony of protesters free to go out and about with signs that say we should end the “lockdown.”)

Black is nothing if not consistent. Back in a March 27 column he said that the “world succumbed to a pandemic of hysteria, more than a virus.”

In his latest column he also said: “This is not a question of monetizing life and exalting commerce.”

But I think that is precisely what this argument amounts to, an argument that suggests those dying are mostly over 70 or have weak immune systems so, let’s the rest of us all get back to business as normal.

Superficially it may sound like a compelling argument, and is something I thought myself back in early March before I understood the basic epidemiology of a pandemic.

I recently chatted with a self-proclaimed Libertarian business owner I know, a man I respect and whom with I chat and joke often about political matters and current affairs. On the topic of COVID-19 he pointed out that 82 is about the average life expectancy in Canada, so why do you need another 10 years beyond that? I didn’t ask him to explain in detail what he meant, but I took it mean that we should not continue to fight this virus with public health measures at the expense of damaging the economy. These people are going to die soon anyway, right?

This notion that the weak are expendable is what Conrad Black argues (even if he denies it), and is what is implicit in the arguments of all who say open the economy no matter the human cost.

Maybe the elderly should be sacrificed so that business can come back sooner and stronger, and maybe culling this cohort of people is just what the economy needs. But if that is what is being argued, then please, I’d like to hear more honesty in the arguments.

Love it or hate it, neoliberal economics is often described as heartless. There is no room for emotions when it comes to cutting costs to increase profits, or reducing taxes in the hope that money trickles down.

Going too far to shut down the economy to save a handful of lives is indeed folly, even if that would be hard to admit. Enacting a mix of public health orders, guidelines and advice is a delicate balance that will in hindsight be criticized by some as being too Draconian and restrictive, while those who lost loved ones to COVID-19 will be left to wonder if only we could have done more.

We could have done more, been more restrictive, but how much worse would that have been for the economy?

We could have done less, not enacted restrictions and our supply of ventilators may not have been able to keep up, our hospitals may have been overwhelmed, and many more may have died.

Hindsight for some pundits and critics looking back on 2020 will almost certainly be just that, 20/20.


Do you have something to add to this story, or something else we should report on? Email:
paul.henderson@theprogress.com

@PeeJayAitch
Like us on Facebook and follow us on Twitter.

Want to support local journalism during the pandemic? Make a donation here.

Coronavirus

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

SLIDESHOW: Chilliwack firefighters battle large blaze at Rosedale chicken barn Friday

Birds were saved but the buildings on Castleman Road were destroyed by fire

Chilliwack Fair kicks off tonight with local talent

Todd Richard and Appaloosa to hit the stage for drive-in concert at fairgrounds

PHOTOS: Moving day for 110-year-old Chilliwack heritage house

House-moving company relocated Hope River Road home to Riverside Drive

UPDATE w/ PHOTOS: Chilliwack fire crews tackle vacant house fire on Rowat Avenue Friday

Empty house was boarded up and behind fencing on lots slated for redevelopment

VIDEO: Chilliwack chicken barn destroyed by fire

Chickens saved from blaze as firefighters work to control large fire

53 new COVID-19 cases, no new deaths cap off week of high infection rates in B.C.

Roughly 1,500 people are self-isolating because they either have COVID-19 or have been exposed to it

Moving on: Tanev scores 11 seconds into OT as Canucks oust Wild

Vancouver beats Minnesota 5-4 to move into first round of NHL playoffs

FURTHER UPDATE: Body removed from Maple Ridge hotel after large police presence

A large contingent of Mounties were at the Art Infiniti Hotel Friday afternoon and evening

Gene editing debate takes root with organic broccoli, new UBC research shows

Broccoli is one of the best-known vegetables with origins in this scientific haze

VIDEO: U.S. Air Force pilot does fly-by for B.C. son amid COVID border separation

Sky-high father-son visit plays out over White Rock Pier

3 Vancouver police officers test positive for COVID after responding to large party

Union president says other officers are self-isolating due to possible exposure

New mothers with COVID-19 should still breastfeed: Canada’s top doctor

Dr. Theresa Tam made the recommendation during World Breastfeeding Awareness Week

Collapse of Nunavut ice shelf ‘like losing a good friend:’ glaciologist

The ice shelf on the northwestern edge of Ellesmere Island has shrunk 43 per cent

Plainclothes Abbotsford police officer deletes cellphone video after drawing gun on innocent man

‘They never asked me what I was doing there, strictly came out with guns, threatening to shoot me’

Most Read