Column: How not to redraw the map in the Middle East

When HarperCollins released an atlas designed for English-speaking children in schools in the Middle East, something was missing.

Now, this wasn’t the best laid plan.

HarperCollins is a giant in the publishing world. But in June 2014 it released an atlas designed for English-speaking children in schools in the Middle East.

“Collins Primary Geography Atlas for the Middle East” proudly tooted that it was an ideal school atlas for young primary school geographers, designed for Middle Eastern schools and would enable students to learn about today’s world by exploring clear and engaging maps.

In portraying the geographical location of the countries of the Middle East it made one astounding – and conscious – decision.

It left the State of Israel off the map.

In its place, it showed Jordan extending all the way to the Mediterranean Sea. Syria, Gaza, the West Bank, and Lebanon were all included. But not Israel.

The howls of shock and dismay reverberated everywhere. This wasn’t an accident. The decision to exclude Israel apparently reflected “local preferences”. In other words, the decision reflected political will. According to its subsidiary Collins Bartholomew, had Israel been correctly positioned it would have been unacceptable to its Gulf customers. So clearly then, it was a marketing decision.

Huh?

What on earth does this do to help children learn with accuracy the countries of the world, their regional positions, and their place in a bigger context during classroom discussions? They all know Israel is right in front of them. And they all know Jordan doesn’t have beach front property. How does this translate into children learning about today’s world in clear and engaging maps? What an insult to Middle Eastern children and Jewish people.

The world knows too well that Palestinians and Arab states have issues with Israel and vice versa. The endless struggle for peace goes on. And it never helped anything or anyone when former Iranian president Mahmoud Ahmadinejad threatened at the stroke of a pen to wipe Israel off the map. Looks like HarperCollins did it for him.

HarperCollins, headquartered in New York is no slouch when it comes to its publishing status. It has almost 200 years of history and has won many major international literary prizes. It has numerous imprints and publishes globally in almost every conceivable genre. It is a giant among publishers. The publishing company was acquired by Rupert Murdoch’s News Corporation, part of his widespread media empire which, for decades, has steadfastly supported the Jewish state. I can’t imagine his position in this embarrassing state of affairs. So you can’t help but ask, given all the meticulous checks and balances that go on in a book’s progress toward publication, how could such a terrible decision be made. Like it or not, it smacks of anti-semitism.

The State of Israel is central to any profile of the Middle East and has been in existence for 67 years. It is recognized by all countries in the region and even Yassir Arafat, founder of the Palestinian independence movement, acknowledged Israel at the Camp David Summit hosted by former President Clinton in 2000.

On the Amazon website, 169 reviewers trashed the atlas. It only got rated a one-star because the rating system doesn’t have a zero.

HarperCollins has done a massive retreat, recalled all copies of the offensive atlas and is pulping them while, at the same time, offering profuse apologies.

But the damage is done. Criticism has been harsh and heavy and rightly so. This kind of delusional mapping does nothing to advance education, serves no one in the long run, and only continues to underscore the hostility that exists toward Israel.

Many might view with dismay that a western world commercial publishing company would pander for profit to extreme opinions. For HarperCollins, this has been a costly lesson.

Just Posted

VIDEO: Grand opening of the Vedder Rotary Loop Trail

It took 24 years to complete the 20.8-kilometre trail which runs along the north and south sides of the Vedder River

Chilliwack’s David Lee Roth impersonator applies for a mistrial in underage sex case

David Kuntz-Angel convicted in August but now questions BC Supreme Court Justice’s ‘mental faculties’

B.C. petition calls for seat belts in new school buses

Agassiz bus driver collects 124,000 signatures in support

Hamper registration by Salvation Army is underway now in downtown Chilliwack

Christmas Central is in old Progress building on Spadina Avenue; applications accepted until Dec. 14

Best filmmakers of B.C. and world featured at Chilliwack Independent Film Festival

This marks the third year for CIFF which will be showing 39 different films at Cottonwood 4 Cinemas

Cold, stormy winter forecast across much of Canada, The Weather Network predicts

In British Columbia temperatures will be slightly above normal and precipitation will be just below normal

UPDATED: Vancouver Island’s Joe gets suspended sentence in Teddy the dog cruelty case

Melissa Tooshley expected in court on Thursday in same case

Nineteen boats carrying invasive mussels stopped at B.C. borders

Waters of Columbia-Shuswap still test mussel-free

Woman ‘horrified’ after being told to trek 200 kilometres home from Kamloops hospital

‘I can’t get from Kamloops back to 100 Mile House injured, confused… no shoes, no clothes whatsoever’

Canadian universities encourage exchange students in Hong Kong to head home

UBC said 11 of its 32 students completing programs in Hong Kong have already left

Midget no more: Sweeping division name changes coming to minor hockey in Canada

Alpha-numeric division names will be used for the 2020-2021 season and beyond

Duncan man gets suspended sentence in Teddy the dog cruelty trial

Joe also gets lifetime ban on owning animals

B.C. pushes for greater industry ‘transparency’ in gasoline pricing

Legislation responds to fuel price gap of up to 13 cents

B.C. woman ordered to return dog to ex-boyfriend for $2,000

After the two broke up, documents state, they agree to share custody of the dog, named Harlen

Most Read