Charter breach leads to dismissal of charges in 2010 impaired driving causing death case

Chilliwack judge rules seizure of hospital records a rights violation in case from Hope, B.C.

A man with a blood alcohol level more than twice the legal limit who crashed a car killing his female passenger had charges against him dismissed Friday due to a breach of his Charter rights.

It was nearly seven years ago that Garett Anthony Saul lost control of his vehicle driving on Highway 1 north of Hope. His vehicle left the road, rolled down an embankment and landed on its roof crushing his female passenger, killing her instantly.

Two hours after the incident, his blood was taken at Fraser Canyon Hospital and found with a blood alcohol content (BAC) of between 0.161 and 0.176, more than twice the legal limit of 0.08. A forensic expert estimated that Saul’s actual BAC at the time of the crash was between 0.183 and 0.219.

The incident occurred on Aug. 9, 2010 and the case dragged on for years, culminating in acquittals in January 2014 on three counts: impaired driving causing death, driving with BAC over .08 causing death; and dangerous driving causing death.

The judge ruled that the Crown could not prove beyond a reasonable doubt that Saul did not engage in bolus drinking. Bolus drinking, or the “last drink” defence, argues that if someone drank a large amount of alcohol right before driving, their BAC might have been below .08 when driving, only rising to the higher level hours later when tested.

The Crown appealed the acquittals and in a unanimous decision on April 14, 2015, the BC Court of Appeal found the trial judge erred in law, and a new trial was ordered.

That trial began in early 2016 at which time Saul’s lawyer Dudley Edwards argued that police violated his client’s Charter rights. That Charter application was based on the fact that after the crash, Saul was taken hospital and a blood sample was taken, but it turned out to be unusable. Then in 2011, investigators got a warrant for Saul’s hospital records to find out what his BAC was after the crash. He did not have a lawyer at that time. In 2014, the Supreme Court of Canada ruled that it violates an accused person’s Charter rights to access hospital records without advice from counsel.

On June 9, 2017, Judge Richard Browning agreed with the defence application and the blood sample was excluded from evidence. Without that, Crown had no other evidence that Saul was impaired at the time of the accident so Browning dismissed the charges.

The sister of the victim wept in court Friday after the decision and was heard to say, “That’s our justice system for you.”


Like us on Facebook and follow us on Twitter.

Just Posted

Opioids, meth, firearms seized at known Chilliwack drug house

Home on Broadway Avenue raided on Feb. 15 where homicide occurred Jan. 31

GW Graham basketball girls savour Fraser Valley championship

It’s been a long wait for the Grizzlies, who lost the FV title game the last two seasons.

Chilliwack Curling Club holding open house

If you’ve ever wanted to try the sport, the club invites you to take the plunge this weekend.

Chilliwack MLA John Martin says NDP budget will hurt business, punish taxpayers

‘Family-owned businesses will struggle to respond to this’

Chilliwack-Kent MLA decries ‘classic, big tax-and-spend’ NDP budget

Laurie Throness says budget relies on strong economy but contains no ideas to help it grow

VIDEO: Top 10 B.C. budget highlights

The NDP is focusing on childcare, affordable housing and speeding up the elimination of MSP premiums

Alberta takes out full-page ads in B.C. over strained relationship

It’s the latest move between the two provinces over progress on Trans Mountain pipeline expansion

B.C. teacher suspended over allegedly using N-word in worksheets

Trafalgar Elementary teacher under investigation by Vancouver School Board

Toddler swept away in Ontario floods

Toddler missing as flooding forces thousands from their homes in Ontario

BC BUDGET: New money helps seniors’ care shortage

Job stability for care aides key to recruitment, union leader says

Mixed messages on B.C.’s efforts to cool hot housing market

Economist says undersupply of homes in Metro Vancouver, Victoria and Kelowna will keep prices high

Foot found near Victoria belonged to missing Washington man

Coroner says no foul play suspected in death of 79-year-old Stanley Okumoto

Questions raised over B.C. NDP’s childcare budget plan

Advocates concerned how to fill 22,000 new spaces for early childhood educators

B.C. family first to receive reimbursement for life-altering arthritis drug

Effective medication used to treat rare form of juvenile arthritis costs $19,000 a month

Most Read