Column: Seven reasons why I hate the BMI

In her latest column, Tanja Shaw takes aim at body measurement that is often misunderstood and misused.

If you search for ‘BMI’ on Google, the first site that pops up is the U.S. National Institute of Health’s BMI (body mass index) calculator.  The site reads “Body mass index (BMI) is a measure of body fat based on height and weight that applies to adult men and women.”

Except it’s not.

The body mass index is a simple calculation of height and weight. It has nothing to do with body fat.

While one can infer that someone weighing more might carry more body fat, it’s not always the case.

The Canadian Diabetes Association describes BMI a bit better.  Their website states “BMI is not used for muscle builders, long distance athletes, pregnant women, the elderly or young children. This is because BMI does not take into account whether the weight is carried as muscle or fat, just the number.”

On a large scale, perhaps BMI can be useful.  BMI can show general nationwide trends in body weight and could be useful for statistics.  But, BMI loses its usefulness when measuring an individual.  Even when BMI is used correctly for a person: as a measure of height versus body weight, I still don’t like it.  Here’s why:

It’s another number.  Even when used within it’s limitations, the BMI is just another number.  And despite knowing that it’s just a number, just like the number on the scale (because, essentially, that’s all it is), it’s easy to get caught up with that number.  A number can undermine all the positive, healthy changes that you make.

It’s inaccurate for more people than just extreme athletes, or muscle builders. BMI does not take into account bone density or muscle mass.  I can easily name many clients at Ascend who are extremely fit and very healthy, but are considered overweight according to the BMI scale.

They are not body builders; they are strong, fit and healthy individuals.  If they lost enough weight to become ‘normal’, then they would become unhealthy.

Some people are naturally small; some people naturally have a stronger build and carry more muscle mass.  Some people wear a size 8 shoe; some people wear a size 10 shoe.

It puts unnecessary labels on people.  Even if you’re aware of the pitfalls of the BMI scale, it can still hurt when the online calculator spits out the words ‘overweight’ or ‘obese’.  In fact, the label ‘normal’ isn’t very effective either.  Congratulations.  You’re normal.

BMI can put unnecessary stress on a healthy individual.  Many people already struggle with negative self-image and reading that you’re ‘overweight’ despite being healthy could further promote poor self-image.

No one really knows how much you’re supposed to weigh.  I know a lot of very fit, healthy people who have a larger body size, or carry a bit of extra body fat.  I know some very unhealthy people who are lean.

It’s useless.  If you legitimately need to lose weight, it’s likely you already know.  It’s also likely that an attentive health professional would be able to assess whether their patient really needs to lose weight without the use of a BMI calculator.   If this is indeed true, what’s the point of using BMI at all?

It can lead to feelings of defeat.

Imagine knowing that even if you lose 50 pounds, you’d still be considered ‘obese’.

Or knowing that getting to ‘normal’ is an unrealistic goal?

If someone legitimately needs to lose weight, any weight loss can positively impact his or her health.  Back to point No. 5: what’s the point of using BMI at all?

BMI is commonly used as a measure of health and predictor of lifestyle related diseases.  While it does have some use to measure statistics across a large population, it’s not an effective way to assess health on an individual level.  In fact, the repercussions of using BMI could even be harmful.

If you think you could benefit from losing weight; talk to your doctor or health professional.

Remember that any healthy lifestyle change, or any weight loss (if you legitimately need to lose weight) can positively impact your health.  Disregard what an online calculator says and focus on being healthy.

 

 

Tanja Shaw is a healthy-eating enthusiast, Rotarian, passionate entrepreneur, mom, runner, and owner of Ascend Fitness Inc.

Tanja and her team of expert fitness coaches inspire and educate Chilliwack residents to make positive and power changes in their lives through physical fitness and sound nutrition.

Visit Tanja  at  ascendfitnesscoaching.com and tanjashaw.com.

Just Posted

Police tape is shown in Toronto Tuesday, May 2, 2017. Statistics Canada says the country's crime rate ticked up again in 2018, for a fourth year in a row, though it was still lower than it was a decade ago. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Graeme Roy
CRIME STOPPERS: ‘Most wanted’ for the week of June 13

Crime Stoppers’ weekly list based on information provided by police investigators

Madalyn Clempson, 18, of Chilliwack sings ‘Hiney Yamin Ba-im.’ She won the Intermediate Vocal Canadian Music award at the Performing Arts BC Virtual Provincial Festival. (YouTube)
Chilliwack youth bring home awards from provincial performing arts festival

Chilliwack’s 18-year-old Madalyn Clempson ‘a bit stunned’ to have won Intermediate Vocal Canadian Music

These three kittens, seen here on Thursday, June 10, 2021, are just some of many up for adoption at the Chilliwack SPCA. (Jenna Hauck/ Chilliwack Progress)
VIDEO: Find Me My Furever Home – Three kittens at the Chilliwack SPCA

Kittens were in ‘rough shape’ when they came into the Chilliwack SPCA, now ready for adoption

Jacqueline Pearce and Jean-Pierre Antonio received the BC Historical Federation Best Article Award on Saturday for their story about translating haiku written in the Tashme internment camp.
Article chronicling haiku in Japanese internment camp near Hope wins award

Tashme Haiku Club’s work was preserved and recently translated, authors write

Two-year-old Ivy McLeod laughs while playing with Lucky the puppy outside their Chilliwack home on Thursday, June 10, 2021. (Jenna Hauck/ Chilliwack Progress)
VIDEO: Chilliwack family finds ‘perfect’ puppy with limb difference for 2-year-old Ivy

Ivy has special bond with Lucky the puppy who was also born with limb difference

Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau participates in a plenary session at the G7 Summit in Carbis Bay, England on Friday June 11, 2021. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Adrian Wyld
Canada donating 13M surplus COVID-19 vaccine doses to poor countries

Trudeau says the government will pay for 87 million shots to be distributed to poor countries

Premier John Horgan speaks as provincial health officer Dr. Bonnie Henry, right, and health minister Adrian Dix look on during a press conference to update on the province’s fall pandemic preparedness plan during a press conference from the press theatre at Legislature in Victoria, Wednesday, Sept. 9, 2020. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Chad Hipolito
B.C. officials to provide details on Step 2 of COVID reopening plan Monday

Step 2 could allow for larger gatherings and a resumption of recreational travel

Indigenous Services Minister Marc Miller is seen during a news conference, Wednesday May 19, 2021 in Ottawa. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Adrian Wyld
Indigenous child-welfare battle heads to court despite calls for Ottawa to drop cases

Feds are poised to argue against two Canadian Human Rights Tribunal rulings

Cannabis bought in British Columbia (Ashley Wadhwani/Black Press Media)
Is it time to start thinking about greener ways to package cannabis?

Packaging suppliers are still figuring eco-friendly and affordable packaging options that fit the mandates of Cannabis Regulations

The Great Ogopogo Bathtub Race has been held in Summerland as a fundraising event. Do you know which Canadian city introduced this sport? (Black Press file photo)
QUIZ: A summer’s day at the water

How much do you know about boats, lakes and water?

A million-dollar ticket was sold to an individual in Vernon from the Lotto Max draw Friday, June 11, 2021. (Photo courtesy of BCLC)
Lottery ticket worth $1 million sold in Vernon

One lucky individual holds one of 20 tickets worth $1 million from Friday’s Lotto Max draw

“65 years, I’ve carried the stories in my mind and live it every day,” says Jack Kruger. (Athena Bonneau)
‘Maybe this time they will listen’: Survivor shares stories from B.C. residential school

Jack Kruger, living in Syilx territory, wasn’t surprised by news of 215 children’s remains found on the grounds of the former Kamloops Indian Residential School

A logging truck carries its load down the Elaho Valley near in Squamish, B.C. in this file photo. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Chuck Stoody
Squamish Nation calls for old-growth logging moratorium in its territory

The nation says 44% of old-growth forests in its 6,900-square kilometre territory are protected while the rest remain at risk

Most Read