Show us the evidence

It’s time for a deep breath in the debate surrounding the chlorination of Chilliwack’s drinking water.

It’s time for a deep breath in the debate surrounding the chlorination of Chilliwack’s drinking water.

Any decision on the future of the city’s water supply should be based on science, not emotion.

The issue is not about the danger of chlorination, but whether there is a necessity for it.

Two weeks ago Chilliwack residents were stunned to hear the Fraser Health Authority order the city to begin chlorinating its water.

Residents here are rightly proud of the water they drink – a pride that may have surprised Fraser Health’s Dr. Marcus Lem when he told city council that Chilliwack’s water might taste good, but he wouldn’t let his daughter touch it.

Reaction was swift. An online petition already has more than 3,000 signatories.

The anger is based on the arbitrary decision by Fraser Health to order Chilliwack to chlorinate its water based on evidence of E.coli contamination in just three instances over the past five years. There is no evidence the bacteria entered the water system, or that it made anyone ill.

The incidents were isolated, the City of Chilliwack insists, and not indicative of the overall condition of the local water supply.

That position has since been echoed by Fraser Health, but not before the reputation of Chilliwack’s water supply has been disparaged by wildly inaccurate media reports and online speculation.

Chilliwack’s water is unique. Unlike most municipalities, it comes from an underground aquifer that protects it and filters it from the kind of environmental incursions found in water drawn from a lake or reservoir.

That purity — maintained through rigorous testing and ongoing maintenance — keeps the water safe.

For Fraser Health, however, those efforts are clearly not enough. It insists that chlorine, a disinfectant used around the world to make water safe to drink, is the only answer.

True, chlorine would pose little risk to residents. It’s not arsenic.

But is it necessary?

Certainly issues of public health should not be decided by petition. However, they should be based on empirical data that is transparent, verifiable and justifiable.

So far, Fraser Health has failed to provide that.

Just Posted

Well-known former B.C. radio personality and politician Barrie Clark dies

Clark remembered as a fair-minded ‘statesman,’ who always saw the big picture

WATCH: Giant Flowers artwork going up at Evans roundabout in Chilliwack

The artwork installation Tuesday was causing very little traffic disruption for Chilliwack drivers

Nature festival, musical science and more for spring break fun

Chilliwack’s libraries, ice rinks and favourite family spots offer up plenty to do

Experts detect risk of rock avalanche above Bridal Falls near Chilliwack

Risk in the one-in-10,000-year is minimal but triggers FVRD to direct growth elsewhere

UFV health fair focuses on taking back health

Health sciences program invites Dr. Cathy van Ingen to speak

Ottawa proposes restricted pot labels, packages

Packaging will include red stop sign with marijuana leaf and ‘THC’

Police officers injured in Trans Mountain pipeline arrests: RCMP

One suffered a head injury after being kicked, another hurt a knee, and a third hurt a hand

Horgan promises new school funding formula in B.C.

Premier addresses B.C. Teachers Federation AGM ahead of contract negotiations starting next year

Reader Photos: First day of spring around British Columbia

Our loyal viewers sent us some of their favourite Spring photos from all corners of the province

Five Canadian kids charged with making school threats

Police say online threats are on the rise

Not even Ellen DeGeneres can get Virtue, Moir to say they’re more than friends

Tessa Virtue, Scott Moir appeared on “The Ellen DeGeneres Show” Tuesday

RCMP warn public to stop pouring gas on fires after three incidents

Police responded to three recent incidents that sent seven people to hospital

BCHL Today: Surrey Eagles in the driver’s seat and Ethan Martini takes a seat

BCHL Today is a (near) daily look at what’s going on around the league and the junior A world.

New Liberal bill would tighten controls on sale, licensing of firearms in Canada

Measures are intended to assist police in investigating gun trafficking and other crimes

Most Read