Public health by referenda?

One of the recurring themes emerging from the chlorination debate was the lack of input from Chilliwack residents.

The recent controversy surrounding the chlorination of Chilliwack water elicited passions rarely seen in civic affairs. And while the level of engagement is impressive, it has also sparked the curious notion that issues of public health should be decided by majority vote.

Democracy is a wonderful thing when public policy is being set, consensus sought, or legislation created.

But it fails when applied to science.

One of the recurring themes emerging from the chlorination debate was the lack of input from Chilliwack residents. Even the city’s own elected representatives were unable to influence the edict laid down by the bureaucrats within Fraser Health.

But that’s how it should be.

The outcome may not have been what many wanted, but the process was based on scientific analysis, not popular opinion. Fraser Health concluded – through investigation – that there was a high probability that public health was at risk; that without the addition of chlorine to the water supply a serious E.coli contamination would occur.

That conclusion can be challenged by examining the data and questioning Fraser Health’s methods, but it can’t be overturned simply because a vociferous group – regardless of how well-intentioned  – feels it did not have a say in the outcome.

Because where would it end?

Should decisions on immunization, for example, be decided by science, or celebrity endorsement?

Should action on climate change be based on the vote of a sometimes skeptical public, or the evidence that points to its reality?

Already some would suggest there is too much political interference in science, whether it’s in politicians influencing classroom content, or governments preventing disclosure of scientific findings that conflict with their own agenda.

The consequences of an E.coli outbreak are potentially deadly. And while we may choose our own personal risks, we don’t have right to ignore the science and extend that risk to the young and the elderly in our community – simply on the strength of a majority vote.

Just Posted

Chilliwack firefighter seeking to reunite Rosedale VFD’s old auxiliary fire pump with antique engine

It’s been four decades, but Pat Liebault is hoping to reunite Rosedale’s auxiliary pump and engine

Council approves rezoning for second housing project in Chilliwack with supports

The longer folks stay outdoors, the harder it is to bring them inside, BC Housing officials says

Massive fire destroys Agassiz dairy barn

Reports say at least one cow died in the blaze

First court date in Chilliwack for man accused of murdering Belgian tourist

Family and friends of Sean McKenzie, 27, filled the gallery for brief court appearance Wednesday

Around the BCHL: Nanaimo Clippers acquire defenceman from Langley Rivermen

Around the BCHL is a look at goings on around the BCHL and the junior A world.

VIDEO: B.C. deer struggles with life-preserver caught in antlers

Campbell River resident captures entangled deer on camera

BC Children’s warns of possible PayPal fraud

Recipients are asked to forward the emails to PayPal

Increased security, staffing changes coming to Colony Farms

Coquitlam Forensic Psychiatric Hospital to get new safety measures, stop patient-on-staff violence

Still too many B.C. seniors in care facilities, on drugs

Seniors Advocate watching use of antipsychotics, opioids

Police raid Langley home in search for ‘extremely violent’ murder suspect

Several law enforcement agencies were at a Willoughby home, hunting for a man charged with murder.

Officials: 3 killed in shooting at Maryland Rite Aid centre

FBI described the Aberdeen incident as an ‘active shooter situation’

The hunt for online herb: feds seek dope on hazy world of pot’s ‘cryptomarket’

In less than a month, Canada to be first industrialized country to legalize recreational marijuana

Despite protests, Russia’s anti-doping agency reinstated

On a 9-2 vote, the executive committee declared RUSADA as having satisfied conditions

Burnaby pedestrian in hospital after being hit crossing busy street

Driver remained on scene, is speaking to RCMP

Most Read