Opinion: The wide gulf that divides

There is a fundamental difference in the way the two sides believe education should be run in this province.

Any hope that Chilliwack students would soon be back in school ended Wednesday with the duelling press conferences of Premier Christy Clark and BCTF president Jim Iker.

The reality of empty classrooms and quiet hallways in what should be the start of a new and exciting school year failed to soften the intransigence demonstrated by both sides in this dispute.

To say they’re not on the same page would be generous. They’re not even in the same book.

That this dispute will lurch to some kind of conclusion is certain. The question is what that reality will look like.

There is a fundamental difference in the way the two sides believe education should be run in this province. It is a rift that dates back to 1998, when then NDP Premier Glen Clark gave the BCTF control over class size and composition in exchange for wage concessions. It was a deal struck between the government and the union – and one roundly denounced by school boards across the province because, they argued, it deprived them of authority to manage their own school districts.

The agreement set rigid caps on teacher-student ratios and class composition. But what might sound good on paper, trustees complained, meant that a new teacher had to be hired if a classroom exceeded the limit by even one student. Making matters worse, there were insufficient funds provided by government, leaving school districts with no choice but to gut their non-instructional staff to avoid a deficit (something they cannot do).

So when the Liberals swept to power, one of the first things they did was strip that language from the contract. If decisions about class size and composition were to be made, they argued, they should be done at the local level and with a degree of flexibility that kept those decisions manageable.

What they failed to check was the legality of the move.

The issue remains unresolved after the B.C. Supreme Court ruled the government had acted unconstitutionally.

It’s still before the courts. However, what’s in question is the way government removed the provision from the last contract, not that it can’t be renegotiated in a future contract.

So here we sit, with the BCTF unwilling to surrender a contract gain its members paid for (and the courts have said was constitutionally valid), and a government unwilling to return to a position it believes was fundamentally flawed.

Granted, there are a host of other issues that are keeping the two sides apart. But the biggest is the ideological shadow over who should control classroom conditions: the employer, or the employee.

And an amicable agreement on that is unlikely to come any time soon.

Just Posted

Time to specify where Chilliwack spending priorities should be

It’s that time of year again when City of Chilliwack engages its citizens to weigh in on budgeting

Council votes to give Chilliwack homeless shelter an 18-month extension

There were more than 40 passionate speakers at city hall who had their say for more than four hours

Chilliwack woman finds mysterious coin among Grandma’s collection

Grandmother died when she was very young and her past is not well known to her mother

VIDEO: Chilliwack musician is embracing the revival of the accordion

Accordionist Debra Kartz has seen the instrument become popular again and wants to inspire the next generation

Fantasy Farms told to stop holding special events on farmland that go against agricultural rules

The Morans say it might spell the end of their seasonal events like Reapers Haunted Attractions

ELECTION 2019: Have Justin Trudeau’s Liberals really cut middle-class taxes?

Conservative Andrew Scheer vows to cut bottom bracket, NDP’s Jagmeet Singh targets wealth tax

Alberta truck convoy plans counter-protest at climate rally with Greta Thunberg

United We Roll organizer says similar protest planned for Swedish teen’s event in Edmonton

Scheer, Trudeau, Singh haggle over potential minority government outcome

If you believe the polls, it appears the Liberals and Conservatives are neck-and-neck

British family deported after ‘accidental’ U.S. border crossing

U.S. officials deny it was mistake, release video of vehicle crossing into Washington from Langley

Man charged in South Surrey torched-SUV killing granted bail

Harjot Singh Deo, arrested in May, was released from custody last week

Kamloops man hangs on to back of stolen truck as suspect speeds away, crashes

The pickup truck was seen leaving the roadway before bursting into flames

VIDEO: Major gridlock after fatal hit-and-run on Highway 11 in Abbotsford

Victim struck just after 6:00 a.m., southbound road closed as police conduct their investigation

Most Read