Just because it’s art, doesn’t make it religious

Re: “Some may find art offensive” (The Progress, Feb. 14)

I hope Mrs. Van Eysinga is arguing that religious art should not normally be placed in public facilities. In a pluralistic society the state must not promote religion. However, not all art is religious, though it may be spiritual. The distinction between the religious and the spiritual is not easily drawn, however, since it is arguably all in the eye of the beholder. But if we are to have any art at all in our hospital? and we should since art helps us heal in ways doctors cannot? then there must be some consensus as to what constitutes “religious” and potentially objectionable art. Otherwise, for those who quote injunctions against the creation of idols from the Bible and the Qur’an, as does Mrs. Van Eysinga, most anything could be construed to be an immoral object of worship.

Is a man on a cross symbolic of Christianity? I would suggest most of us would affirm that to be the case. It would be an extraordinary artist who could portray a crucifixion without making a visitor to the hospital think of the traditional iconography associated with Jesus. Even a crucifixion depicted in an irreverent manner in order to challenge Christian beliefs would still not be acceptable in our hospital. Certain symbols, figures and settings are obviously religious and, at the very least, should be subject to open and thorough debate before appearing in a public space.

But the art soon to be on display at the Chilliwack Hospital (the opening ceremony is this coming Friday) is hardly “religious” in any normal sense of the word. If any single term is fitting, it would be “medicinal.” The images of a medicine woman, a red cedar spindle whorl, and a healing wheel with five words, can hardly strike any viewer as an explicit attempt to persuade or dissuade anyone regarding a particular creed or dogma. Such images address the art of healing that must be available not just for devout believers but for all our relations. Any attempt to assign theological meaning here is entirely out place, and says far more about the commentator than the art itself. Such art is neither religious nor offensive to any reasonable person. In fact, consider how the art in question seems the opposite of “religious” in that it does not distinguish between the spiritual and the physical as does Christianity, Islam, etc, and instead encompasses a holistic concept of health that is remarkably absent in Western medicine; the artists respectfully represent our elders and their lore, the earth and the herbs it provides, and the circles in life that require balance.

Additionally, the hospital is located upon what used to be aboriginal land and therefore it is very appropriate that aboriginal art is displayed. I went to the hospital today and noticed many first nations people there. While there I also took an informal poll of visitors regarding the hospital’s choice of artwork, and found everyone supportive of the decision made by Fraser Valley Health.

And finally, regardless of whether or not aboriginal art deserves special treatment due to its near annihilation by the forces of colonialism, in terms of cultural and even economic impact artists like Greene, Horne, Pennier and Krulicki, produce beautiful work that is very popular both here and abroad; they add breadth and depth–and money–to our community. Hard to object to that!

Tom Hartley

Just Posted

RCMP ask for help to locate missing Chilliwack man

Kyle Travis Neil travelling in a red, Ford F250 and he maybe be in need of medical attention

UPDATED: Chilliwack councillor’s expenses being sent to the RCMP

Decision to have expenses audited and shared with RCMP taken at special meeting of council

Risk of thunderstorm this afternoon for Vancouver Island and Lower Mainland

A special weather statement calls for heavy rain and wind over the next 48 hours

Update: Search called off for missing plane between Edmonton and Chilliwack

Search efforts were concentrated along the Highway 5 corridor between Valemount and Kamloops

Two Chilliwack incumbents seek re-election to Cultus Lake Park Board

David Renwick and Darcy Bauer form a mini-slate

VIDEO: Neighbours fear impact of B.C. tent city residents

Greater Victoria residents opposed to campers voice concerns at provincial campground

Man arrested after carjacking, collision, pepper spray attacks in Vancouver

Vancouver police say one man is in custody after a chaotic scene of events in the downtown core

Canadian investigator says World Anti-Doping Agency got a bad deal from Russia

A Canadian lawyer says the World Anti-Doping Agency rushed into accepting a bad deal by reinstating the country’s drug-testing program.

Fashion Fridays: Rock some animal print

Kim XO, lets you in on the latest fall fashion trends on Fashion Fridays on the Black Press Media Network

New evacuations ordered because of Florence flooding

Emergency managers on Friday ordered about 500 people to flee homes along the Lynches River

B.C. doctor weighs in on the kid ‘screen time’ debate

A Maple Ridge mother opens up about her children’s use of tablets, smartphones and television

Volunteer-based safety team gets city funding to continue work in Vancouver

Good Night Out is a non-profit society that works to keep people safe at night on Granville Strip

More than 35 B.C. mayors elected without contest

No other candidates for mayor in the upcoming local election in 22 per cent of B.C. cities

Most Read