Column: Lack of credibility was Ghomeshi accusers’ downfall

The high profile trial saw three witnesses take the stand. But their testimonies crashed and burned under the expert cross examination

Last Thursday, former CBC radio host Jian Ghomeshi walked out of court a free man after being acquitted on four counts of sexual assault and one charge of overcoming resistance by choking.

The high profile trial in February saw three witnesses take the stand. But their testimonies crashed and burned under the expert cross examination by Ghomeshi’s defence lawyer Marie Henein.

Henein was able to clearly show inconsistencies, deceptive conduct, breaches of oath to tell the truth, withholding of information to the police and the prosecution, and “playing chicken” with the justice system. As one glaring hidden fact after another surfaced, people were dumbstruck with the flagrant disregard of the oath to be truthful. Many wondered just how well the prosecution had prepared the complainants – “L.R.”, Lucy Decoutere, and “S.D.” – for what they would face.

The judgment was met with anger by many women who supported the witnesses and who decried the perception of blaming the victim. But it wasn’t that the system was set up to blame the victim but that the victims set themselves up to fail.

And in light of the facts, Justice William Horkins verdict was absolutely right.

“The success of this prosecution depended entirely on the Court being able to accept each complainant as a sincere, honest and accurate witness,” said Judge Horkins in his Reasons for Judgment. “Each complainant was revealed at trial to be lacking in these important attributes. The evidence of each complainant suffered not just from inconsistencies and questionable behaviour, but was tainted by outright deception. The harsh reality is that once a witness has been shown to be deceptive and manipulative in giving their evidence, that witness can no longer expect the Court to consider them to be a trusted source of the truth. I am forced to conclude that it is impossible for the Court to have sufficient faith in the reliability or sincerity of these complainants. Put simply, the volume of serious deficiencies in the evidence leaves the Court with a reasonable doubt.”

The trial has opened up a wider dialogue on how sexual assault is prosecuted and defended in Canada. The fallout is of course whether women in the future will be more reluctant to report their own victimized circumstances.

Sexism and prejudice still surface. Last year, details of a sex assault case in 2014 involving a homeless 19-year-old woman surfaced. During the trial, she was callously asked by Justice Robin Camp, “Why couldn’t you just keep your knees together?” That comment earned Camp a review of his conduct by the Canadian Judicial Council.

Sexual assault cases are harsh, difficult to prove, and horribly embarrassing. According to Statistics Canada, 91 per cent of these cases are never reported to the police. Women shrug it off and walk away.

Probably looking over their shoulders at the Ghomeshi case are the women alleged to have been sexually assaulted by Bill Cosby in the U.S.  In the U.K., all those women allegedly abused as children by the late TV personality Jimmy Savile might also have what-if questions.

Credibility is everything in “he-said-she-said” trials where affirmative consent is a flip from “no means no” to “only yes means yes”. But credibility of the complainants in the Ghomeshi trial was profoundly missing.

“At the end of this trial, a reasonable doubt exists because it is impossible to determine, with any acceptable degree of certainty or comfort, what is true and what is false,” wrote Judge Horkins.

The legal system demands explicit truth and the three women who testified should have been better primed for the rigid demands of a criminal trial. There’s no wiggle room for inconsistencies, 11th hour disclosures, omissions, hidden collusions, or veiled deceptions.

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Police tape is shown in Toronto Tuesday, May 2, 2017. (Graeme Roy/The Canadian Press)
CRIME STOPPERS: ‘Most wanted’ for the week of Oct. 18

Crime Stoppers’ weekly list based on information provided by police investigators

UBC geoscientists discovered the wreckage of a decades-old crash during an expedition on a mountain near Harrison Lake. (Submitted photo)
Wreckage of possibly decades-old airplane crash discovered on mountain near Harrison Lake

A team of Sts’ailes Community School students helped discover the twisted metal embedded in a glacier

Mark Strahl is speaking in the House of Commons on Oct. 20, 2020, on a Conservative motion to create a special committee to look into the WE charity scandal. The speech will be posted live on his Facebook page. (Facebook image)
VIDEO: Chilliwack-Hope MP Mark Strahl to speak on WE scandal today

Prime Minister has said Conservative motion for ethics committee could trigger election

Plow equipment clearing the roads on Dec. 13, 2016 focused on Priority 1 and 2 roads. (City of Chilliwack)
Dozens of Chilliwack roads could get upgraded for snow removal

But side streets mostly remain as priority 4, rarely if ever plowed based on resources available

More and more electric cars are on the road, but one Chevy Bolt owner was shocked to see how much his BC Hydro bill skyrocketed once he started charging the vehicle. (Black Press file photo)
Rosedale man sees significant spike in BC Hydro bill after purchasing electrical vehicle

An increase should be expected, but Brian Chwiendacz experienced a 200-plus per cent hike

FILE – People wait in line at a COVID-19 testing facility in Burnaby, B.C., on Thursday, August 13, 2020. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Darryl Dyck
167 new COVID-19 cases, 1 death recorded as B.C. enters 2nd wave

Three new healthcare outbreaks also announced

This 2020 electron microscope image made available by the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases shows a Novel Coronavirus SARS-CoV-2 particle isolated from a patient, in a laboratory in Fort Detrick, Md. THE CANADIAN PRESS/AP-NIAID/NIH via AP
At least 49 cases of COVID-19 linked to wedding in Calgary: Alberta Health

McMillan says the city of Calgary has recently seen several outbreaks linked to social gatherings

Officers with the Lower Mainland Emergency Response Team were at a White Rock home Tuesday (Oct. 20) to assist Vancouver Police Department with execution of a search warrant. (Contributed photo)
ERT, VPD response to White Rock home connected to homicide: police

Search underway in the 15800-block of Prospect Crescent

The official search to locate Jordan Naterer was suspended Saturday Oct. 17. Photo courtesy of VPD.
‘I am not leaving without my son,’ says mother of missing Manning Park hiker

Family and friends continue to search for Jordan Naterer, after official efforts suspended

A bear similar to this black bear is believed responsible for killing a llama in Saanich on Oct. 19. (Black Press Media file photo)
Bear kills llama on Vancouver Island, prompting concerns over livestock

Officers could not track the bear they feel may not fear humans

Join Black Press Media and Do Some Good

Pay it Forward program supports local businesses in their community giving

Is it time to start thinking about greener ways to package cannabis?

Packaging suppliers are still figuring eco-friendly and affordable packaging options that fit the mandates of Cannabis Regulations

Bernard Trest and his son Max, 10, are concerned about B.C.’s plan for students in the classroom. He was one of two fathers who filed a court application in August to prevent schools from reopening if stricter COVID-19 protections weren’t in place. That application was dismissed last week. (Contributed photo)
B.C. dad pledges to appeal quashed call for mandatory masks, distancing in schools

Bernard Trest and Gary Shuster challenged health, education ministries’ return-to-school plan

RCMP crest. (Black Press Media files)
RCMP cleared in fatal shooting of armed Lytton man in distress, police watchdog finds

IIO spoke to seven civillian witnesses and 11 police officers in coming to its decision

Most Read