Chilliwack Law Courts. (Black Press file)

Chilliwack Law Courts. (Black Press file)

COLUMN: Chilliwack judge refuses to hear guilty plea and sentencing over the phone

‘The sentencing judge must be in a position to confront the offender, meet his eye’ - Judge Kristen Mundstock

Should a judge be able to look into the eyes of a criminal offender when accepting a guilty plea and handing down a sentence?

In rejecting an over-the-phone attempt by a man to do just that in Chilliwack provincial court on May 27, Judge Kristen Mundstock responded with a firm “yes.”

J.S. is charged with one count of publication of an intimate image without consent, an act known colloquially as revenge porn. The details of the case have not yet come out in court as the matter did not go to trial because of the intended guilty plea.

That hearing took place in courtroom 204 with just three human beings physically present. Judge Mundstock, the court clerk, and yours truly. On speaker phone at the hearing were J.S, his lawyer David Duncan, and Crown counsel James Whiting.

The plan was for Judge Mundstock to accept the guilty plea over the phone followed by a joint submission for a 15-month conditional sentence order.

“We did come to full agreement on virtually 100 per cent of what we are going to put forward as a resolution package,” Whiting told the court.

On May 8, 2020, the Provincial Court of B.C. put forth a “notice to the profession and the public” regarding the commencement of “some court operations” under the current COVID-19 pandemic. Under the category of “process for resolution of non-urgent criminal disposition matters” regarding individuals who are not in custody, there are three conditions to allow for this: the accused and counsel agree to appear by telephone; both sides agree to a similar sentence not involving incarceration; and the disposition is done in 45 minutes.

Anyone who has ever participated in criminal court proceedings knows that nothing takes just 45 minutes.

After pre-ambles, brief questions and answers from Mundstock, Whiting and Duncan, a request by Duncan to disconnect to talk to his client, and a publication ban application on the victim’s name where even I was asked for input, we were 25 minutes into the proposed 45-minute hearing.

Judge Mundstock’s hesitation about the process was evident from the outset.

“I want to hear from counsel with respect to your submissions on why it is I should exercise my discretion in the absence of Mr. J.S.,” she said.

Speaking for the Crown, Whiting explained that the case was to be scheduled for three days of voir dire (trials within trials), and six days of trial involving witnesses across four provinces. A “fairly extensive undertaking,” according to Whiting, one that J.S.’s lawyer suggested would “help the court to clear its backlog” by dealing with a guilty plea and joint sentencing over the phone.

But Mundstock pointed out that the matter is indictable, i.e., very serious, and there is a fundamental principle in our justice system that the judge be able to confront the offender to deliver not only the sentence but the reasons for sentence.

I have covered countless trials, pleas, bail and sentencing hearings, and I’ve always seen the offender’s face, observing mannerisms and emotions that can only be properly identified, even if imperfectly, in flesh.

• READ MORE: Man gets jail time for posting explicit photos of ex-girlfriends

• READ MORE: Chilliwack Crown asking for nine years prison for prolific offender

Speaking one or two words as he did over the phone in that hearing, it occurred to me that J.S. might have been sitting on a wooden bench weeping with contrition. Or, maybe, his eyes were rolling back into his head, feet up, gin and tonic in hand on a sunny patio.

His physical positioning and attitude was much more likely somewhere in between, but did he feel closer to eye-rolling or contrition?

We simply don’t know, and this is not an insignificant fact. Some human interactions simply do not lend themselves to audio only. We can never truly know what another person is feeling, but vastly less so if they are communicating with us over the phone.

Justice Mundstock could not come around to the idea of taking a plea and handing down sentence to a man over the phone, let alone hearing submissions from both sides including case law in 45 minutes. Mundstock pointed to section 650 (1) of the criminal code that states an accused “shall be present in court.”

This didn’t cut it.

“The sentencing judge must be in a position to confront the offender, meet his eye and explain the wrong in the sentencing and the reasons for sentencing,” Mundstock told the two lawyers. “The offender must participate in the justice system in a meaningful way and I’m not satisfied that participating by telephone is meaningful.”

The plea and sentencing was put over to a date in August with J.S. present.


Do you have something to add to this story, or something else we should report on? Email:
paul.henderson@theprogress.com

@PeeJayAitch
Like us on Facebook and follow us on Twitter.

Want to support local journalism during the pandemic? Make a donation here.

CoronavirusCourt

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Alisa Gusakova was one of two Grade 12 Chilliwack students who received a $5,000 Horatio Alger Canadian Scholarship earlier this year. Now, a fundraiser has been created for the teen after her mother was killed. (Jenna Hauck/ Chilliwack Progress file)
Fundraiser launched for daughter of Chilliwack woman killed

Money raised will help Chilliwack teen attend UFV to earn business degree

Chilliwack Search and Rescue volunteers say that a call on April 17 on Vedder Mountain was affected by bikers who rode through the rescue site, throwing rocks onto members and the patient. (Chilliwack Search and Rescue image)
Chilliwack Search and Rescue team, and patient, sprayed with rocks and dirt during rescue

Volunteer crew speaks out after riders on Vedder Mountain show no courtesy at accident scene

Agassiz Fire Department has been called to an ATV rollover on Harrison East Forest Service Road on Sunday, April 18, 2021. (Google Maps)
Agassiz Fire called out to ATV rollover incident on Harrison FSR

Morning call follows exceptionally busy Saturday as temperatures soar in Fraser Valley

A Chilliwack Search and Rescue truck heads down Vedder Road towards Cultus Lake to assist a dirtbiker with a broken leg. (Paul Henderson/ Chilliwack Progress)
Emergency crews, SAR busy with three separate outdoor recreation incidents in Chilliwack area

Calls in 1 afternoon include ATV collision, parachuter who fell from tree, dirtbiker with broken leg

Philomusica Chorus and Ensemble released ‘All Good Gifts’ on YouTube on April 3, 2021. (YouTube)
Chilliwack chorus shares latest song with ‘same love, enthusiasm’ as pre-pandemic music

Philomusica Chorus and Ensemble recently released its version of ‘All Good Gifts’ on YouTube

Vancouver resident Beryl Pye was witness to a “concerning,” spontaneous dance party that spread throughout social groups at Kitsilano Beach on April 16. (Screen grab/Beryl Pye)
VIDEO: Dance party erupts at Vancouver’s Kitsilano Beach to the dismay of onlookers

‘It was a complete disregard for current COVID-19 public health orders,’ says Vancouver resident Beryl Pye

File photo. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Graeme Roy
One man dead after shooting in Downtown Vancouver

This is Vancouver’s fifth homicide of the year

A syringe is loaded with COVID-19 vaccine at a vaccination clinic run by Vancouver Coastal Health, in Richmond, B.C., Saturday, April 10, 2021. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Jonathan Hayward
B.C. to open up COVID vaccine registration to all B.C. residents 18+ in April

Registration does not equate to being able to book an appointment

(Black Press file photo).
Multiple stabbings at Vancouver Island bush party

Three youths hospitalized after an assault in Comox

Cannabis bought in British Columbia (Ashley Wadhwani/Black Press Media)
Is it time to start thinking about greener ways to package cannabis?

Packaging suppliers are still figuring eco-friendly and affordable packaging options that fit the mandates of Cannabis Regulations

Selina Robinson is shown in Coquitlam, B.C., on Friday November 17, 2017. British Columbia’s finance minister says her professional training as a family therapist helped her develop the New Democrat government’s first budget during the COVID-19 pandemic, which she will table Tuesday. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Darryl Dyck
B.C. finance minister to table historic pandemic-challenged deficit budget

Budget aims to take care of people during pandemic while preparing for post-COVID-19 recovery, Robinson said

Police tape is shown in Toronto Tuesday, May 2, 2017. Statistics Canada says the country's crime rate ticked up again in 2018, for a fourth year in a row, though it was still lower than it was a decade ago. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Graeme Roy
CRIME STOPPERS: ‘Most wanted’ for the week of April 18

Crime Stoppers’ weekly list based on information provided by police investigators

Each spring, the Okanagan Fest-of-Ale is held in Penticton. This year, as a result of the COVID-19 pandemic, the festival will not be held. However, beer is still available. How much do you know about this beverage? (pxfuel.com)
QUIZ: How much do you really know about beer?

Put your knowledge to the test with this short quiz

Pall Bearers carrying the coffin of the Duke of Edinburgh, followed by the Prince of Wales, left and Princess Anne, right, into St George’s Chapel for his funeral, at Windsor Castle, in Windsor, England, Saturday April 17, 2021. (Danny Lawson/Pool via AP)
Trudeau announces $200K donation to Duke of Edinburgh award as Prince Philip laid to rest

A tribute to the late prince’s ‘remarkable life and his selfless service,’ the Prime Minister said Saturday

Most Read