A worker employed by a Chilliwack-based agricultural employer seen throwing a chicken in an undercover video in 2017 filmed by California-base animal rights activists Mercy For Animals.

Undercover video uncertainty delays start of trial for Fraser Valley chicken abuse

Judge reluctantly agrees to one last adjournment so defence can buy custom-made secret camera gear

Delays continue in the case of alleged chicken abuse at Fraser Valley poultry farms as lawyers for the two companies accused continue to refuse to enter a plea or select a mode of trial.

Lawyers for chicken catching company Elite Farm Services Ltd., the company’s owner Dwayne Paul Dueck, and Ontario-based Sofina Foods were in a Chilliwack courtroom Monday where, for the third time, Judge Gary Cohen asked the two lawyers if they were ready to arraign.

“The short answer is ‘no’” Martin Finch said. He represents Elite and Dueck.

At previous appearances in May and in June, Finch and Sofina’s lawyer Morgan Camley said the disclosure from Crown regarding the undercover video evidence and the equipment used by a California-based animal rights group was incomplete.

The case dates back to 2017 when animal rights activist group Mercy for Animals released undercover video filmed at Fraser Valley farms that shows employees ripping live birds apart as well as stomping, kicking and throwing chickens.

• READ. MORE: One year later, still no charges in Chilliwack chicken abuse case

• READ MORE: Chilliwack company charged with animal cruelty claims video evidence manipulated

WARNING: This video shows disturbing images of animal abuse that may upset some viewers

More than a year later Elite, Dueck and Sofina were each charged with 38 counts under the Health of Animal Regulations in connection with the alleged abuse of birds at local farms.

Employees were fired, the companies expressed dismay at the actions of those employees, and the BC Chicken Marketing Board expressed disgust at the practices seen in the video.

But it’s that video that remains the crux of the case, and in turn also the delays in getting the case to trial.

The problem leading defence to continue to delay arraignment is, essentially, that if the video evidence they have seen was manipulated, then defence likely wants the case heard in front of a jury. If an expert who examines the video evidence determines the videos have not been edited in ways beyond already admitted, then the case would be simpler and better suited in front of judge alone.

”We’ve had to go through these steps because this key evidence is not just a bit of evidence, it’s the evidence,” Camley told the court July 30.

And up until recently, defence did not know what video equipment was used by Mercy For Animals so their expert couldn’t form an opinion on the video evidence. Since a court appearance in June and the one on July 30, the expert, David McKay, president of Blackstone Forensics out of Vancouver, has learned what was used is custom-made undercover camera equipment made precisely for this purpose.

“These are highly secretive types of devices that are created for the purposes of secret videoing,” Finch told the court.

When told of the defence request for yet a third delay that has been before the courts for 223 days and refers to allegations more than two years old, Judge Cohen expressed immediately displeasure having already agreed to adjourn the proceedings twice to deal with the technical matters.

“If it’s going to be longer than one week I’m going to deem you elected judge and jury,” Cohen told the lawyers.

Sofina’s lawyer Camley responded by starting to express what she said was her concern with that possible decision.

Cohen interrupted.

“I understand your concern, but the concern from the Supreme Court of Canada is Jordan,” he said, referring to the 2016 R v Jordan decision that created a timeline within which all Canadian court cases have to be resolved. That is, 18 months in provincial court and 30 months in Supreme court.

Camley responded by saying without the video recorder analyzed by the expert, she doesn’t know how many experts will be needed for defence.

“These are the utmost in serious charges that have significant ramifications,” she said.

“Even murder charges have to be tried within 30 months,” Cohen said.

“In murder charges, my expectation is the disclosure would have been done in a more abundant way,” Camley responded.

Cohen’s response, something also suggested by Crown, was, in effect, that defence could enter a plea and elect a mode of trial that day, and worry about the details of evidence leading up to the trial or a preliminary inquiry.

Cohen told the lawyers he was considering invoking an order under section 536 of the criminal code. The section gives a judge authority to order election where an accused declines or refuses to arraign.

Finch responded that section 536 is meant to deal with an accused who actively refuses to plead or who is so indifferent or passive to have no position at all.

“That is not the situation here at all,” Finch said. “It’s not as though we are standing silent.”

After a brief recess, defence lawyers returned — with Crown counsel Jessica Lawn still opposed — to say they. would waive the delay period to avoid Jordan ramifications.

Cohen said since Jordan was his greatest concern, he was inclined to grant further time for defence experts to get hold of the video equipment used by the animal rights activists.

The case was put over to Aug. 28 at 2 p.m. in Surrey at which time the judge said defence would have to arraign or he would do it for them.


@PeeJayAitch
paul.henderson@theprogress.com

Like us on Facebook and follow us on Twitter.

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

 

A worker employed by a Chilliwack-based agricultural employer seen throwing a chicken in an undercover video filmed by Mercy For Animals.

Just Posted

Highway 1 single vehicle rollover west of Lickman Road on Oct. 30, 2020, at 7:45 a.m.
Highway 1 west of Chilliwack saw single-vehicle rollover

The crash west of Lickman Road slowed down traffic Friday morning

Photo courtesy of Correctional Service of Canada.
Prisoner convicted of first-degree murder escapes Mission Institution

When 10 p.m. count was conducted, staff discovered Roderick Muchikekwanape had disappeared

Pre-registration required for the drive-in 2020 flu immunization clinics at Chilliwack Heritage Park on Nov. 3 and 4, and Nov. 9 and 10. (Chilliwack Division of Family Practice)
First ever drive-in flu shot clinics coming to Chilliwack next week

Roll up your sleeve, drive inside the barn at Heritage Park, and park for a few minutes to get shot

B.C. taxpayers could be on the hook for upwards of $27 million in total payouts for MLA pensions. (file)
Pensions are adding up for defeated, retiring MLAs: Taxpayers’ group

Martin and Throness would get $28,000 per year, lifetime pensions estimated ~$700K

Sooke’s Paul Larouche enjoys gold panning along the Sooke River, looking for small treasures. (Aaron Guillen/News Staff)
VIDEO: Island man finds niche audience by gold-panning on YouTube

Paul Larouche, 29, with over 215,000 subscribers, opens up about his journey

CBSA. (Black Press Media File)
4 sentenced in B.C. steroid smuggling, distribution ring that spilled into U.S.

Canadian Border Services Agency announced the results of a lengthy investigation it called ‘Project Trajectory’

Search and Rescue Technicians carry a stretcher to the CH149 Cormorant during a 442 Squadron Search and Rescue Exercise in Tofino on February 28. (Photo by: Cpl Joey Beaudin, 19 Wing Imaging, Comox)
Father and son found dead after weeklong search near Pemberton

The father and son had set out for a day of mushroom picking last Thursday

A full moon rises over Mt. Cheam on Saturday, Feb. 8, 2020. (Jenna Hauck/ The Progress)
Rare full moon, Daylight Saving makes for a uniquely spooky Halloween – despite COVID-19

We can’t host costume parties but this weekend is still one for the history books

A woman wears a face mask and plastic gloves while browsing books as a sticker on the floor indicates a one-way direction of travel between shelves of books at the Vancouver Public Library’s central branch, after it and four other branches reopened with limited services, in Vancouver, on Tuesday, July 14, 2020. (THE CANADIAN PRESS/Darryl Dyck)
B.C. reports 234 new COVID cases, 1 death of senior who had attended small birthday party

Roughly 5,700 people are isolating due to being exposed to a confirmed case

Join Black Press Media and Do Some Good

Pay it Forward program supports local businesses in their community giving

Is it time to start thinking about greener ways to package cannabis?

Packaging suppliers are still figuring eco-friendly and affordable packaging options that fit the mandates of Cannabis Regulations

Provincial Health Officer Dr. Bonnie Henry speaks Thursday (Oct. 29) during a news conference held at Fraser Health office, in video posted to Facebook. (Photo: Government of British Columbai/Facebook)
COVID-19 ‘disproportionately’ affecting Fraser Health: Henry

Health region has about 75 per cent of B.C.’s active cases

A study by SlotsOnlineCanada notes there is at least 88 hours of top-rated horror movies for Canadians to consume this Halloween. (Unsplash)
Spooks and Chill study reveals Canada’s favourite horror flicks

88 hours of top-rated horror movies can fill COVID-19 Halloween

Most Read