Samples of bottom ash recently tested positive for high concentrations of cadmium at Metro Vancouver's incinerator in Burnaby.

Existing incinerator fails toxicity tests

“Burning garbage simply doesn’t make sense," says FVRD chair Sharon Gaetz in the wake of disturbing test results.

Environmental impacts will be “inevitable” if Metro Vancouver insists on burning garbage, said FVRD chair Sharon Gaetz.

Metro’s existing incinerator in Burnaby is continuing to exhibit a pattern of failed toxicity tests.

Samples of bottom ash recently tested positive for high concentrations of cadmium – some at twice the allowable levels for landfills.

“It defies logic that Metro Vancouver is continuing with a proposal to build a second, larger incinerator while they have repeatedly shown that they cannot even properly manage the smaller one already in operation,” said Gaetz in a FVRD release.

FVRD is expressing concern and frustration in wake of a Metro Vancouver staff report from solid waste services GM Paul Henderson. It showed that bottom ash loads have failed 19 times out of 479 tests so far this year, with eight tests coming back at more than twice the limit.

“This unsettling report demonstrates the environmental problems that inevitably arise when you burn garbage,” said Gaetz.

The testing failures are different from the high cadmium levels detected a year ago in some fly ash that came from scrubbers in the waste-to-energy plant’s stack. Operator Covanta Energy failed to report those until they were already dumped at the Cache Creek regional landfill.

FVRD officials want to pursue greener initiatives for solid waste management, avoiding garbage incineration all together.

Trouble with incoming ash loads was first flagged in 2007, when some bottom ash exceeded allowable levels of lead, but the report says subsequent testing determined it wasn’t hazardous to workers and steps were taken to ensure compliance with the landfill’s operating certificate. Bottom ash ends up in the Vancouver Landfill at Burns Bog in Delta.

Metro was advised starting in April of this year that some bottom ash was exceeding leachable cadmium levels. Henderson also noted that the amount of cadmium in the waste stream is increasing over time, which suggests that cadmium toxicity in bottom ash is a problem that will likely get worse, not better.

FVRD’s newest Solid Waste Management Plan, set to be finalized in 2014, includes a more aggressive ‘Zero Waste’ strategy, which involves removing considerably more recyclable material from the waste stream with cost-effective, readily available technology.

On the proposal to build a second incinerator, Chair Gaetz said: “Burning garbage simply doesn’t make sense. We know that there are cheaper, greener, and more energy efficient approaches to waste management.”

FVRD favours what they call “maximized” waste reduction, meaning more jobs, and less waste to the landfill, and protection of the sensitive airshed.

“The FVRD believes we have a responsibility to our citizens and our environment to maximize recycling and recovery efforts in the region, and to think beyond burning garbage.”

Some alternatives being discussed by FVRD are at:

According to Metro, sources of cadmium in the waste stream are thought to have increased in recent years.

Household batteries are the main source, particularly rechargeable batteries, including e-device batteries. A much smaller fraction likely comes from plastics.

Metro officials say they intend to further study cadmium sources in the waste stream and to work with Covanta to ensure the treatment of bottom ash to neutralize metals is effective.

–with files from Jeff Nagel

Just Posted

Mathieu Caron leads Chilliwack Chiefs to shutout win over Wenatchee Wild

Chilliwack’s netminder stopped 29 pucks Saturday night in a BCHL Showcase game at Prospera Centre.

Chilliwack Chiefs erase three goal deficit in overtime win

Down 3-0 to the Cowichan Capitals, the Chiefs came back to win 4-3 in the BCHL Showcase match.

Chilliwack man feeling helpless about puppy stolen while at church

Evidence of neighbour trespassing and accusing him of dog neglect not enough for RCMP

UPDATE: Missing Chilliwack man has been found

Chilliwack RCMP is thanking the public for keeping an eye out

UPDATED: Chilliwack councillor’s expenses being sent to the RCMP

Decision to have expenses audited and shared with RCMP taken at special meeting of council

Conservation officer frees B.C. deer from flotation gear mishap

BC Conservation Officer Service is reminding residents to keep backyards clear of entanglements

Lions earn stunning 35-32 OT win over Ticats

Epic comeback lifts B.C. past Hamilton in CFL thriller

Czarnik nets 3 as Flames dump Canucks 5-2

Calgary picks up exhibition win over Vancouver

Ottawa to name new ambassador for women, peace and security, Freeland says

Chrystia Freeland also confirmed Canada would spend about $25 million to fund number of initiatives

‘A little bright spot:’ Ottawa residents rescue dog trapped beneath rubble

Freelance journalist says rescue of a dog trapped under rubble was happy ending amid chaos in Ottawa

B.C. deaf community wants different sign languages on federal accessibility act

Advocates also want Indigenous Sign Language to be recognized on the Indigenous Language Act

Remainder of Vancouver Whitecaps season filled with ‘must-win’ games: coach

With Vancouver currently sitting four points out of a post-season spot, each contest is crucial

VIDEO: B.C.-born firefighter remembered by MP in emotional speech

Family asks first responders to look after one another in wake of suicide, growing concerns of PTSD

Airline has ‘close call’ with drone while en route to B.C. airport

Jazz Aviation reported the drone sighting near Vancouver to the RCMP and Transport Canada

Most Read