David Kuntz-Angel was convicted of numerous sex charges involving an underage complainant. In BC Supreme Court on Nov. 18, 2019 he applied for a mistrial, questioning the “mental faculties” of Justice Neill Brown. (Twitter/Brantford Expositor)

David Kuntz-Angel was convicted of numerous sex charges involving an underage complainant. In BC Supreme Court on Nov. 18, 2019 he applied for a mistrial, questioning the “mental faculties” of Justice Neill Brown. (Twitter/Brantford Expositor)

Chilliwack’s David Lee Roth impersonator applies for a mistrial in underage sex case

David Kuntz-Angel convicted in August but now questions BC Supreme Court Justice’s ‘mental faculties’

A B.C. Supreme Court Justice’s mental faculties were put under question on Monday by a Chilliwack man convicted of sexual interference with an underage female.

David Kuntz-Angel was scheduled for a sentencing hearing following his conviction in August on two counts of sexual interference, two counts of invitation to sexual touching, one count each of assault and uttering threats.

• READ MORE: Chilliwack’s David Lee Roth pretender convicted of sexual interference of underage girl

• READ MORE: Chilliwack man wanted for sex crimes dating back to 2006

Instead of a sentencing hearing, however, defence counsel Chantal Paquette advised the court she was asking the court to consider a mistrial, citing questions over the mental health of Justice Neill Brown who convicted Kuntz-Angel after a 20-day trial.

Justice Brown was not in court on Monday, instead the case was being heard by Justice Dev Dley out of Kamloops. His status is unclear and an emailed request for information to the Supreme Court’s communications officer was not immediately responded to.

“We do need to inquire about how to get information as to why Justice Brown was replaced and I make those inquires because observations throughout the course of the trial have raised, in my view, legitimate concerns about the mental faculties of Justice Brown and that they may have been impaired and they may have impaired his ability to preside over the trial,” Paquette told the court.

Crown counsel Michelle Wray responded firstly that this was a “very uncommon” application, adding that her office had only been served with notice on Thursday so did not have a strong position.

Wray did say that Crown had not made similar observations in the trial regarding Brown’s mental faculties, something that was not addressed by any parties during the trial or by those in the gallery.

“We do not support [the] allegations that Justice Brown was suffering from mental impairment in the trial,” Wray said, adding that the Crown also did not support Paquette’s request to get personal information about Justice Brown’s health, or to inquire why he is no longer presiding over the case.

“I have some concerns this is an appeal masquerading as a mistrial application,” Wray said.

Kuntz-Angel faced 12 charges in total during the trial that involved his grooming the complainant from the age of eight to 19 when she complained to police. Justice Brown acquitted him of sexual exploitation, sexual assault, assault causing bodily harm, and one count of procuring. But he convicted Kuntz-Angel of the most serious charges.

Going by David Kuntz-Angel in the court system, the 54-year-old has too many aliases to list, not least of which is David Lee Roth, the former lead singer of American rock band Van Halen, whom he has pretended to be in numerous situations over the last 20 years from Ontario to Chilliwack.

Kuntz-Angel was accused of grooming the complainant from the age of eight to 19 when she complained to police. A number of witnesses were called who testified to seeing the couple in highly inappropriate situations. The complainant herself spent considerable time on the stand in often uncomfortable circumstances.

At the end of trial, Justice Brown found the victim’s testimony to be credible and he credited her summoning the courage to testify. Kuntz-Angel, however, was found to be “obsequious” at times and “condescending” at others.

After the brief submissions on the mistrial application in court on Nov. 18, Justice Dley said he would make no immediate decisions, rather he ordered the Crown and defence to see if they could resolve matters. If not, the next step would move forward with the mistrial application, a somewhat unique situation that may prove precedent-setting in the courts.

Given Paquette’s submission that she observed behaviour in the trial that questioned Justice Brown’s mental faculties, she pointed out that she might have to be a witness at a mistrial hearing meaning she would have to step down as defence counsel.

Justice Dley laid out the consequences of a mistrial hearing, which he pointed out should be apparent to everyone. First of all, if a mistrial was declared, the entire proceedings would have to be commenced again.

He also pointed out that Kuntz-Angel is in jeopardy for all the original charges again, even those for which he was found not guilty, and for the Crown it means presentation of all evidence again.

“And that is always difficult for a victim, to relive the events that form the basis for these charges,” Dley said.

See www.theprogress.com for more on this story, including updates on when the file will be back in court.

• RELATED: OPINION: When observation affects what is observed


@PeeJayAitch
paul.henderson@theprogress.com

Like us on Facebook and follow us on Twitter.

 

David Lee Roth (left) and the Chilliwack man who for years has impersonated him, David Kuntz-Angel (right). Kuntz-Angel was convicted of the most serious charges he faced involving sex with an underage girl in August 2019, but on Nov. 19, 2019 he applied for a mistrial. (Twitter/Brantford Expositor)

David Lee Roth (left) and the Chilliwack man who for years has impersonated him, David Kuntz-Angel (right). Kuntz-Angel was convicted of the most serious charges he faced involving sex with an underage girl in August 2019, but on Nov. 19, 2019 he applied for a mistrial. (Twitter/Brantford Expositor)

Just Posted

Chilliwack’s Sierra Bergen is one of 25 girls chosen to join the full-time Vancouver Whitecaps women’s REX (Regional Excel) program. (Submitted photo)
Chilliwack soccer standout Sierra Bergen selected for Whitecaps REX program

Only 25 players from Western Canada born between 2004 and 2006 were chosen for the full-time program

Thirteen-year-old Allison Hickman was last seen in Chilliwack May 14. (RCMP photo)
RCMP say missing Surrey teenager was last seen in Chilliwack

Allison Hickman was last seen in the downtown Chilliwack area on May 14

The Portal homeless shelter on Yale Road in downtown Chilliwack on April 7, 2021. (Paul Henderson/ Chilliwack Progress file)
The Portal’s days are numbered in downtown Chilliwack

Homeless Shelter that faced opposition by neighbours closing its doors even earlier than expected

Chilliwack mom Brianna Jervis was greeted by her children, Kenzie and Wilson, after she completed a 10-kilometre run to help raise money for the maternity department at Chilliwack General Hospital through the annual Run for Mom event. (Submitted)
Run for Mom brings in thousands of dollars for Chilliwack maternity department

Fundraising continues with raffle to raise money for maternity equipment at CGH

Dr. Euiseok Kim is the medical director of the new Abbotsford post-COVID-19 recovery clinic. (Submitted)
Post-COVID-19 recovery clinic opens in Abbotsford

New facility following model of first clinic which opened in Surrey

A prowling coyote proved no match for a stray black cat who chased it out of a Port Moody parking lot Friday, May 14. (Twitter/Screen grab)
VIDEO: Cat who chases away coyote asked to join Port Moody, Vancouver police 

Caught on camera Friday, the black cat jumps out from under a parked car and runs the wild animal out of a vacant lot

The Combined Forces Special Enforcement Unit released a poster Tuesday, May 18 featuring the names and photos of more suspects involved in Lower Mainland gang conflict.
Police issue warning for 9 more men involved in Lower Mainland gang conflict

B.C.’s gang task force says it’s expecting ‘violence to continue and escalate’

A restaurant server on White Rock’s Marine Drive serves customers on a roadside patio. Indoor dining and recreational travel bans have been in effect since late March in B.C. (Peace Arch News)
B.C.’s COVID-19 infection rate falls to 411 cases Tuesday

360 people in hospital, up slightly, two more deaths

The Banff National Park entrance is shown in Banff, Alta., Tuesday, March 24, 2020. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Jeff McIntosh
Minister asks Canadians to camp carefully in national parks as season starts

Kitchen shelters in Banff National Park closed, trails on Vancouver Island will only be one-way

Cannabis bought in British Columbia (Ashley Wadhwani/Black Press Media)
Is it time to start thinking about greener ways to package cannabis?

Packaging suppliers are still figuring eco-friendly and affordable packaging options that fit the mandates of Cannabis Regulations

Names of those aboard the ship are seen at Komagata Maru monument in downtown Vancouver, on Tuesday, May 18, 2021. The City of Vancouver has issued an apology for its racist role in denying entry to 376 passengers aboard a ship that was forced to return to India over a century ago. Mayor Kennedy Stewart says discrimination by the city had “cruel effects” on the Sikhs, Hindus and Muslims aboard the Komagata Maru, which arrived in Burrard Inlet on May 23, 1914. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Darryl Dyck
Vancouver mayor says sorry for city’s role in turning away South Asians in 1914

Kennedy Stewart has declared May 23 as the annual Komagata Maru Day of Remembrance

A crew of WestCoast WILD Adventures employees tackled an onslaught of litter left at the ‘Locks of Love’ fence at Wally Creek on May 2. (Anne-Marie Gosselin photo)
Litter woes consume popular ‘Locks of Love’ fence on B.C.’s Pacific Rim

Popular view spot near Tofino plagued by people hanging masks and other unwanted garbage

Vincent Doumeizel, senior advisor at the United Nations Global Compact on Oceans, as well as director for the Food Programme for the Lloyd’s Register Foundation, pulls up some sugar kelp seaweed off the French coast in April 2020. He was the keynote speaker during the opening ceremony of the inaugural Seaweed Days Festival. (Vincent Doumeizel/Submitted)
Let’s hear it for seaweed: slimy, unsexy and the world’s greatest untapped food source

Experts talks emerging industry’s challenges and potential at Sidney inaugural Seawood Days Festival

Troy Patterson, a Cadboro Bay 15-year-old, got a virtual meeting with B.C.’s environment minister months after he started an online petition calling for construction of the Coastal GasLink pipeline to stop. (Jake Romphf/News Staff)
B.C. teen’s 23,000-name Coastal GasLink petition gets him an audience with the minister

15-year-old Saanich high school student and George Heyman discussed project for about 30 minutes

Most Read