Suspension questions

Bruins radio colour man Jacob Bestebroer writes a weekly column in the Chilliwack Progress during the Western Hockey League season.

At maybe the worst possible time of the season, the Chilliwack Bruins find themselves without the services of captain Brandon Manning.

The 20-year-old was suspended seven games for a hit on Kamloops Blazer D-man Austin Madaisky, and that is the subject of this week’s column by Bruins radio colour man Jacob Bestebroer.

Manning was given a seven game suspension on Wednesday for a play in last Friday’s game that left Madaisky with a fractured C-7 vertebrae. Madaisky is expected to make a full recovery but will not play again this season.

Now, the debate begins.

Too much, or too little?

If you haven’t seen the hit, I encourage you to watch it on Youtube.com (search Manning suspension) because explaining it in words is difficult. The wrong word at any point in the explanation could easily imply guilt on one of the two parties involved and that wouldn’t be fair.

Here’s an admittedly simple version of the play.

Manning dumped the puck into the Blazers zone and continued in on the forecheck.

Madaisky headed for the corner as well.

The two made contact right around the goal line as they headed into the corner. Madaisky spun around awkwardly and hit the boards upright back first.

On any play like this the order of concern is obviously first for the condition of the player who is hurt. Then you move on to what (if any) the penalty should be.

Madaisky stayed down for a few minutes before heading to the dressing room. The severity of the injury was not discovered till the next day.

The penalty to Manning was a five minute major for boarding and a game misconduct.

As with all non-fighting majors, the league reviews to decide if further punishment is deserved.

That took five days.

Was the contact between the two players before they reached the general area of the puck against the rules?

Possibly, but we see it all the time. Ironically, it happened on the very first shift of the next game.

You could make the argument that no contact between players should be allowed in a situation like this until one player has possession of the puck. Agreed, but again, we see it happen without any penalty called all the time.

Of course, thankfully these plays usually do not end like this one did.

Was it a hit from behind? Definitely not. Was there intent to injure? Absolutely not. Was the severity of the injury factored in? I don’t know.

Some people think Manning got off easy. Some think he was dealt with too harshly. My wish is that with every suspension of three or more games the league would issue a statement explaining the process that led to determining the length of suspension.

Unfortunately that is not the case so we are left to form opinions without all the needed information.

jb@chilliwackbruins.com

Just Posted

Latest plan is to fly trapped fish by helicopter over Big Bar slide

Multi-pronged plan set in motion to freesalmon blocked by landslide in the Fraser River

Light trucks are being converted to gas and propane in City of Chilliwack fleet

It came to light when tenders for certain trucks were deemed non-compliant without propane option

Family of missing Chilliwack senior with dementia frustrated with situation, heartened by community support

Nine days since Grace was last seen the question remains: ‘How can an 86-year-old just disappear?’

One-day delay for trial of Chilliwack pastor facing child porn charges

Main Street Church’s former executive pastor John Vermeer set for seven-day trial

Rail group to bring plan to Abbotsford council

Group is calling for plans to run trains on rail line between Chilliwack and Surrey

VIDEO: Young couple found dead in northern B.C. had been shot, police say

Chynna Noelle Deese of the U.S. and Lucas Robertson Fowler of Australia were found along Highway 97

VIDEO: Man found dead near B.C. teens’ truck could be linked to a double homicide

RCMP said they are looking for Kam McLeod, 19, and Bryer Schmegelsky, 18, of Port Alberni

Okanagan Air Cadet challenges gender-exclusive haircut policy

Haircut regulation inspires challenge around gender identity

Hazmat incident closes down Lower Mainland street

One person is believed to be dead, police said

Unsealed record suggests U.S. man convicted of murdering Vancouver Island couple left DNA on zip tie in 1987

William Talbott is set to be sentenced Wednesday in the murders of Jay Cook and Tanya Van Cuylenborg

Pride flags stolen from Lower Mainland church

Went missing sometime Friday night, says Maple Ridge reverend

VIDEO: Bystander training gains traction as tool to prevent sexual harassment, violence

Julia Gartley was sexually assaulted after an event, and no one stepped in to help

Two brands of ice cream sandwiches recalled due to presence of metal

The Canadian Food Inspection Agency issued a recall on Iceberg and Originale Augustin brands

Sexual assaults, extortion on the rise even as crime rates stay low: Stats Canada

Rates of police-reported sexual assault rose for the fourth year in a row

Most Read